Hero image

Capt'N Pete's Dairy Dock, LLC

7425 S Wayne St, Hamilton, IN 46742 United States of America
Open Today:
1 1

Amenities

Service options
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in
Accessibility
Offerings
  • Coffee
  • Comfort food
Dining options
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Dessert
  • Seating
Amenities
  • Restroom
Planning
Payments
  • Debit cards
  • Credit cards
Children
  • Good for kids

Best WLM Reviews

The service was amazing, staff was very friendly and the food was really good. Burgers were good and a bunch different ice cream and sides options!
Awesome place beautiful spot great hometown goodness excellent service 1000s of ice cream options and lots of food choices to
It won’t let me rate 0 stars but I want to be very clear that you don’t even deserve one. Stood in line for 25 minutes beginning at 7:10. Got to the counter at 7:33 and was told the kitchen was closed (at 7:30). I’m sorry, that’s not how you treat your customers. Won’t be back.
The owners really made the store look beautiful this year! New tables, new umbrellas & the beautiful flowers! I love that they added corn hole boards for families to enjoy! They change their soft serve flavors every week so there’s always something new to try! Definitely recommend coming up to Hamilton to enjoy a nice day at the lake and enjoy some ice cream & food here!
We were just at Captain Pete’s…. They handed us two of our cones at the drive up and then we waited 35 minutes for the rest of our ice cream and our two cones were soup, we nicely asked for our two cones to be remade because our parents were waiting for them at home. He said “yeah give them to me” we handed them to him and he slammed them on the ground and got ice cream all over our car and slammed the window shut. We then drove around and went in, and he yelled ”oh they came in here and want to fight!!” with families and little kids in there. and said “call the cops because you want to fight!!” and he told us “there’s a hose in the back you can clean it off yourself” it was absolutely horrible. The worst part is he was an older gentleman working with a bunch of kids. We will never ever go there again. Absolutely horrible.
I think this might be a great place for the locals, but for me as a drive through experience, it was a bit of a let-down. I wish when ice cream shoppes had flavors that show they have them, they actually would. If they run out, remove the container from the showcase. It is so frustrating to look at closed lids and then pick a flavor, only to be told they don’t have that flavor. If I could have either seen it was empty, or it was not in the case, I would have chosen something else. I just got the vanilla soft serve and honestly it was just about as good as McDonalds, but more expensive. Their pup cup was cute!
Very disappointing. My family used to go for ice cream every Sunday, well we did up until today. We decided to grab some food today instead. When they brought the drinks we had two, not three. My wife goes up and they get her a drink. Food comes out and we are missing a fry. I go up and ask and they acted as tho I didn’t know what we ordered. So I was not pleased. Told the lady charge me for the fry and bring it out. When the manager came out with our fry starts saying not to yell at his employee. Rude as hell. The whole situation could have been handled way better. The manager was probably all of 18 years old. Told us to take our business elsewhere if we didn’t like it, so I guess my 20 dollars a week will go elsewhere. I can over look slow service and the occasional mess up from high school kids working a job. I won’t tolerate a rude manager. That kids parent should be ashamed!!
My wife and I often visit here after a fun day at the beach. I'm always anxious to see the new flavors of the week. Ice cream is delicious, and the owner and staff are very friendly. Highly recommend!

Quick Facts About Capt'N Pete's Dairy Dock, LLC